Old Pepper 4 Year Rye
Wow what a great rye. I think it holds its own with Willett and even beats out Pikesville. Keep up the great store picks Thirds Base!
You will be hard pressed ( I don't personally know of any) to find a better rye for the money . The Old Pepper line is one of my favorites.
I like my cocktails on the stronger side so I try to use a solid (but not prohibitively expensive) BP rye when making my Manhattans (perfect with 1/2 sweet and 1/2 extra dry vermouth) and angostura bitters stirred NEVER SHAKEN! JEP BP fits the bill perfectly and even carries a 4yr MGP statement! Woohoo